Thread: Two identical ads, one shows up in search one doesn't

Two identical ads, one shows up in search one doesn't

Sorry if I'm missing something obvious, but a couple of my ads stopped showing up on location search. I then created an identical ad, and it does show up on location search. I can't figure out what's going on:

Shows up:
http://surfgearexchange.com/ads/64-mccoy-2/

Doesnt:
http://surfgearexchange.com/ads/64-mccoy/

If you go to the surfboards category and put in the zip code from the ad, only one of the posts shows up.